×
Grades level iconsGrade 9
Genre information iconInformational, Media, Persuasive
Resource type iconWriting

Here, Queer, Yet Not Really

Mercury, 826CHI
A student explores the representation of LGBTQIA+ minorities and youth in US pop culture.

If you look at representation in entertainment and media, most people would say that pretty much everyone is represented in everything. I hate to say it, but not everyone is really represented, and not in the right way. There may be characters of color, but they are most likely Mexican, Black, East Asian, or an unidentified ethnicity, along with being atheist or Christian, cisgender, and/or straight. You never really get to see characters who wear hijabs, are Latin American but not Mexican or Puerto Rican, practice Hinduism, or identify as nonbinary. Even when minorities are represented, they are not always represented in the right way—especially when it comes to the representation of queer people.

When it comes to representation of minorities, queer people in this case, in entertainment and media, there will always be stereotypes and labels. Like for someone who is transgender, in real life or in fiction. Stereotypes of being transgender include being oppressed and rejected by family and peers, being in drag or being a cross-dresser, having had or planning to have sex reassignment surgery, or being gay. I know of people who are transgender who do and don’t fit with these statements. But I will go out and say this now: stereotypes can be true, but they can also be false.

In entertainment, where stereotypes are alive and well for queer characters, portrayals of non-cisgender and non-straight characters have become more realistic since the late twentieth century. There is still a long way to go when it comes to proper representation of queer identities, relationships, and stereotypes. But not all are so bad. You can look at Santana and Brittany or Kurt and Blaine from the musical teen drama Glee, for example. Both relationships are healthy, yet of course they have their thin ice moments when touching coming-of-age topics such as coming out, bullying, cheating, and breakups. Kurt and Blaine both express their love of the arts, Broadway, and fashion, as well as having the feminine qualities of your stereotypical gay teenage boy. Yet these qualities are not exaggerated. Santana and Brittany, however, have no fairly visible stereotypes incorporated in their characters. Their relationship isn’t the usual “butch-femme” lesbian relationship. Brittany isn’t the bisexual to not commit in a serious relationship. And Santana being a Latina puts out a good example of a queer person of color. Qualities from both of these relationships put out great examples of your more modern queer youth.

Of course there is good representation, but not all representation is good. Yes, you see people who are gay, bisexual, or lesbian in a relationship, drag queens (sometimes), or people who are transgender. But where are other existing gender identities and sexual orientations? People who are religious, people of color, or disabled people, who are also in queer relationships? Queer people in healthy, lasting relationships? Drag kings? Transgender relationships? Perpetuating realistic and healthy stereotypes in good ways?

An example of this absence would be the constant killing of queer women in entertainment, from the stray bullet that killed Tara Maclay in Buffy the Vampire Slayer to the other stray bullet that killed Lexa in The 100. I have no idea why it’s mostly by gunfire that wonderful queer women are killed, but these deaths also killed off great relationships. Both Tara and Lexa had just gotten back with their significant others before being killed. What message does this show? That queer women can’t live happy lives in healthy relationships with the person they love? Hopefully, one day, we will know the answer without a bogus statement about getting viewer ratings up.

And now for the things we all know and love: bad stereotypes and misconceptions. Like Tyrell Wellick from Mr. Robot, who perpetuates the really bad stereotype of bi and pan characters not being able to commit in a relationship and sleeping around. And of course he shows this by sleeping around, having an unhealthy obsession with another character, and just being a real schemer. A fail at telling queer history was the movie released in 2015 titled Stonewall, which attempted and failed to tell the story of the Stonewall Riots in 1969 in New York. Just by looking at the trailers you could tell what went wrong in this white-cis-male production: no lesbians, drag queens, transgender people, or many people of color. In the movie, there was no mention, showing, or dedication to the drag queens of color or transgender women of color who started the riots. Sylvia Rae Rivera was probably spinning in her grave after that movie was released.

Then there are, of course, other identities to be represented that aren’t just LGBT: QI+ was added to the current acronym for a reason. Before going off air, the MTV show Faking It had the first intersex character portrayed by an intersexactor (pretty big, even if it was for one episode) and the first recurring out intersex character on television. And most gender-bending characters I’ve seen who are well played out and not overly stereotypical are found in anime. Haruhi Fujioka from Ouran Highschool Host Club and Haruka Tenou, AKA Sailor Uranus, from the Sailor Moon franchise are both rumored to have gender identities under the trans umbrella (specifically genderfluid). These very, very few characters who live beyond the binary and have identities that are underrepresented in media and entertainment are one step closer to proper representation of queer topics and characters. Some media is telling the stories of queer characters from underrepresented religions, some of whom are disabled as well. Like Laila, a teenager with cerebral palsy, who is in a lesbian relationship with Khanum, who is blind—both women are from India and are Hindu, as seen in the film Margarita With A Straw. Or Rasha Zuabi, a lesbian, practicing Muslim, and Syrian refugee from Degrassi: Next Class.

Queer people being represented in an informational way is not as common as it should be. I haven’t seen or heard of any textbook or class that speaks of queer history, current civil rights struggles, or sex education units. The only thing gay-related that was taught to me in school was HIV/AIDS. Even in the news, where most of the content is devastating in order to raise viewer ratings, I barely saw the stories of over seven transgender women’s murders or that of the first person to be legally recognized as agender. Is this because this would just ruffle the feathers of people in high positions or “concerned” parents? Maybe . . . probably . . . but who can tell for sure these days.

This may seem like a lot of representation, but it is realistically very little. And like the way society is able to give people who aren’t minorities proper representation and rights, these things should be available to those who are minorities as well. Teach the young and old about what really goes on, and tell them there needs to be equality, in entertainment and in real life.

Would you think that I believe queer people and other minorities have a long way to go?

YES.

Do you agree with me?

That is up to you.

Download the Materials

No materials available for download.

See More Writing at this Level

Grades 9–10
Writing
My First…

by Chris O., Age 15, 826 Valencia

Memoir
Narrative

A freshman describes their first day of school on their own.

Grades 8–9
Writing
The Saga Continues

by Calvin, 826michigan

Narrative

A laugh-out-loud personal narrative about a crush. Has your heart ever beat so fast it might get a speeding ticket and a $500 fine?

Grades 9–10
Writing
Dandelion

by Elizabeth W, 826 Valencia

Poetry

Even though we may look different, we remain united with one another.

Grades 8–10
Writing
David & Daniel

by David & Daniel, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

In this heartfelt exchange of letters, two students bond over food, videos games, and some scary adventures.

Grades 9–12
Writing
Giving Shelter

by Steysi Hailee, 826LA

Narrative

A student reflects on a small moment and single sacrifice that transformed her outlook on giving.

Grades 9–10
Writing
The Rez Girls Are Powerful!

by Navayah, 826 MSP

Fantasy/SciFi
Narrative

Through redefining a label, a student reclaims a piece of their identity.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Yerba Buena Gardens/Jardines de Yerba Buena

by Christian Z., Age 14, 826 Valencia

Poetry

A poet recounts his day out at the Yerba Buena Gardens.

Grade 9
Writing
No One Can Help You

Yashasa Fluker, Grade 9, 826 New Orleans

Informational

A student describes the eeriness of liminal spaces.

Grade 9
Writing
You Deserve More

by Sabrin, Grade 9, 826 MSP

Narrative
Persuasive

In this letter from the Essential Words lesson, 9th grader Sabrin discusses how she feels both happy and sad, and thanks nurses nationwide for bringing her peace through their work.

Grade 9
Writing
The Great Under

by Kyla Edwards, 826 New Orleans

Fantasy/SciFi
Narrative

This creative short story explores a snapshot of what a future New Orleans might look like amid climate change.

Grades 9–10
Writing
Thoughts Onto Paper

by Pretty S, 826 Valencia

Memoir
Narrative

Peek into the mind of a student who considers artistic influences in her life.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Booking an Adventure

by William, 826LA

Memoir
Narrative

A teen discovers the power of books to transport him to another world, and shares his excitement about becoming a published author.

Grade 9
Writing
Note to Self

by Gilbert, 826LA

Memoir
Narrative

One teen writes a letter to his 14-year-old self, citing his past fears but looking towards his present, a brighter future.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Confused

by Anonymous, Grade 8, 826 Boston

Poetry

In this poem, a student reflects on identity.

Grades 8–10
Writing
Bryanna & Kayla

by Byanna & Kayla, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

Two students across one city bond by writing letters to each other about the people they love most.

Grades 7–9
Writing
Fruit Woman Saves the Day

by Pia, 826NYC

Fantasy/SciFi
Narrative
STEM

A student reimagines food justice: Fruit Woman must convince Junk Food Man and Cheesecake Boy to eat their fruits and vegetables.

Grades 9–11
Writing
Gift of Love

by Samuel Wang, Grade 10, 826NYC

Poetry

A poem about the complexity of love exchanged during the holidays.

Grades 7–9
Writing
My Language

by Fahima Dahir, 826 MSP

Poetry

A poem about the strength and limitations of language and shared culture.

Grades 9–12
Writing
Haunting Picture

by Jazlyn Moses, 826 National

Narrative
Persuasive

One student explores their online persona and the lasting importance of conscientious social media practices.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Shout-Out Poem

by Anjum, 826CHI

Poetry

A shout-out poem to some things missed (Hyderabad) and celebrated (Mom).

Grades 9–10
Writing
Matricide: Addressing Climate Change

by Maggie Munday Odom, Kailua, HI

Poetry

This poem personifies Earth as a mother coping with the brutalities of climate change.

Grades 8–12
Writing
It Might Not Always Disappear

by Sian Laing

Narrative

When Instagram becomes an unsightly battlefield.

Grades 9–10
Writing
Retrospect

by Kevin G, 826 Valencia

Narrative

This narrative calls us to see the world through the perspectives of others.

Grades 9–12
Writing
A Glitch in the System

by Soraya, 826NYC

Poetry

This student’s powerful piece reveals the essence of racial injustice.

Grades 7–9
Writing
New Sport: Pencils

by Jason, 826michigan

Informational

Making bottle flipping look like child's play, this piece outlines rules for the new, competitive Fantasy Sport "Pencils".

Grades 9–12
Writing
Racial Autobiography

by Bianca Morcho, 826 MSP

Memoir
Narrative

A personal essay that explores the different shades of the Black Lives Matter movement.

Grades 9–12
Writing
The Achilles Heel

by Salma Khalif, 826 MSP

Poetry

A powerful poem that lifts up Black women.

Grades 9–12
Writing
What Becomes of the Brokenhearted

by Ryker, 826michigan

Informational
Narrative

Liner notes that showcase the meaning and musicality of the Jimmy Ruffin song “What Becomes of the Brokenhearted.”

Grades 9–10
Writing
Where I’m From

by Charles, 826 MSP

Poetry

A student reflects on his life, stemming from the life of his father.

Grade 9
Writing
Strength, Bravery, Selflessness, and Dedication

by Sammie, Grade 9, 826 MSP

Narrative
Persuasive

In this letter from the Essential Words lesson, a freshman at South High School in Minneapolis thanks care workers for supporting our local and national communities during this global pandemic.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Jazmine & Vanessa

by Jazmine & Vanessa, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

Over a series of letters, two compassionate and resilient students develop a deep friendship sealed in writing.

Grade 9
Writing
Gone

by Kalyn Jackson, 826 New Orleans

Fantasy/SciFi
Narrative

Through this short story, Kalyn explores ideas of home and change in an altered world.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Kneel Down for What You Believe In

by Caroline, 826 Valencia

Informational
Persuasive

A student explores U.S. soccer player Megan Rapinoe’s decision to kneel in protest during the national anthem.

Grades 9–12
Writing
This Is Me

by Lucas Hu, 826 Boston

Poetry

A poem about staying true to yourself during a challenging transition

Grades 9–12
Writing
Marcela

by Lisbeth M.F., 826NYC

Narrative

A story about how Marcus becomes Marcela.

Grades 8–10
Writing
Reuben & Giselle

by Reuben & Giselle, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

Two students write to each other about where they came from, what they love, and a few mishaps along the way in an exchange of letters.

Grades 9–10
Writing
An Indescribable Place

by Samantha Wint, Grade 9, 826 Valencia

Poetry

This poem uses metaphors and similes to explore many dualities of the narrator's life.

Grades 8–12
Writing
A Challenge

by Shayne Williams

Narrative

Discover what one student experiences when they tuck their phone away for a whole day.

Grades 8–10
Writing
Henry & Matthew & Santiago

by Henry, Matthew, & Santiago, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

A compilation of letters written by three students across one city filled with thoughts on books, sports, music, family, and musings on Valentine’s Day.

Grades 8–9
Writing
Ode to My Grandfather

Amara, 826 New Orleans

Poetry

An ode celebrating an important figure in this student’s life.

Grades 9–12
Writing
Technology Gives Me a Way In

by Jonas K., 826 National

Narrative
Persuasive

A student explores the paradox of how technology is used amongst teenagers.

Grades 8–10
Writing
Christopher & Bryan & Jahir

by Christopher, Bryan, & Jahir, 826CHI

Memoir
Narrative

In an exchange of letters, three students across one city share stories about where they came from and the places that matter most.

Grade 9
Writing
Used To Be Booty, Now I’m Good

by Rey, Grade 9, 826 MSP

Fantasy/SciFi
Narrative

Aliens give this student superpowers to help him fulfill his greatest dream.

Grades 9–10
Writing
Beat of the Drum

by Aniah, 826 MSP

Poetry

A student is lifted up by the dance of her ancestors.

Grades 9–12
Writing
Stupid Blue Screen

by Vanessa Ramon-Ibarra, 826DC

Narrative
Poetry

Living in the digital world can create unwanted attachments, as one student laments.

Grades 7–12
Writing
My Family Interview

by Johnny Vasquez, 826 MSP

Narrative

A family interview reveals a mother's painful past and shines a light on her persistence.

Grades 8–9
Writing
What walking the red road means to me is

by Mariah Valenzuela, Minneapolis, MN

Poetry

From the forthcoming anthology, Poets in Revolt!, this poet uses her voice to speak up for those who have been silenced in the indigenous community.